Reducing killing and poaching of endangered species by understanding and limiting opportunities for crime

The main threat to conservation of rare animals is often thought to be the loss of suitable habitat. However, poaching, illegal killing and the trade in endangered animals play a major role in the catastrophic declines of these animals, like rhinos and elephants in Africa, parrots in the Neotropics, and pangolins in South-East Asia. Dr. Ronald Clarke, Professor of Criminal Justice and Director of the Center for Conservation Criminology at Rutgers University, examines wildlife crimes through the lens of environmental criminology and seeks ways to reduce criminal predation of endangered species. While the importance of law is acknowledged, and while the Center works on improving the functioning of ranger patrols, Dr. Clarke and team seek to understand and, ultimately, to close down the opportunities that permit these crimes to happen.

This preventive work faces enormous challenges given the vast and remote areas often inhabited by threatened species, inconsistent and weak support from state or national governments, frequently high levels of corruption, and poverty in the countries concerned. Despite these problems, Dr. Clarke and the Center have published important projects in its short existence, studying the ban on the international trade in ivory, the decline of neotropical parrots, and how tigers in Indian reserves could be made more visible to tourists using CCTV cameras so as to protect tigers from poaching. Using a criminological approach to understand the endangerment of species and re-analyzing data collected by biologists, conservation scientists, and conservation NGOs, Dr. Clarke and his team conduct their own field studies to obtain the data that is needed.

A sample of other projects presently underway include:

  • Retaliatory Killings for Livestock Predation of Tigers and Leopards in India: One of the principal threats to tiger and leopard conservation occurs when these predators leave the reserves to kill cattle belonging to local villages. Villagers then retaliate by shooting or poisoning the tigers and leopards when they return to the kill. Dr. Clarke and his team are examining various ways to prevent this retaliatory killing, including compensation schemes and supplying secure corrals for villagers to keep their livestock in at night.
  • The Role of Illegal Fishing in the Decline of Albatrosses: A global problem, but particularly in the southern oceans, the albatross population has precipitously declined over the past 20 years due to longline fishing. When albatrosses strike at the baited hooks, they become entangled in the fishing and drown as the line sinks in the water. A large proportion of longline fishing is committed by illegal fishing boats, and Dr. Clarke and his team are documenting the precise effects of illegal fishing on albatross populations and seeking to identify preventive measures.
  • The Illegal Provision of Pangolin Meat in Restaurants in South China: Pangolins are scaly anteaters that are now endangered in many parts of East Asia because they are in high demand for their succulent meat. Despite being protected by law, they are hunted by people who sell their meat to restaurants in South China. Dr. Clarke and his team are conducting phone interviews in the southern and northern parts of China to compare and estimate the scale of the problem. In so doing, Dr. Clarke hopes to derive solutions to reduce the demand for pangolin meat in China.
  • The Illegal Wildlife Trade in the Peruvian Amazon. One of Dr Clarke’s graduate students, who is a Peruvian, is visiting street markets in jungle ports to determine which protected animals and plants are being illegally sold. He has recorded many instances of illegal sales of small monkeys, birds, and snakes, all of which are protected by law.  By interviewing the sellers about their prices, sources, and opinions regarding taking animals from jungles to sell, Dr. Clarke’s team studies ways to prevent such crimes by recommending other sources of profit and compensation.

Dr. Ronald Clarke was born during World War II in Tanganyika (now Tanzania) in British East Africa, where the colonial government had sent his father to oversee the construction of new roads, and where his father met his mother, the daughter of German missionaries. One of his clearest memories in Africa was accompanying his father on some of his week-long “safaris” to inspect the road building work and to pay the worker’s wages. Travelling along half-constructed roads in his father’s pick-up truck, the two would occasionally see herds of giraffes, zebras, wildebeest and other animals in the land of Kilimanjaro, the Serengeti, and the Ngorongoro Crater.

Dr. Clarke’s life in Africa came to an abrupt end at ten year’s old when, worried about schooling, his mother took him and his siblings to live in post-war England. The family lived in a small seaside town where the children attended local schools, viewed by local people with suspicion, not least because their mother was German. Nonetheless, they soon settled down to an ordinary existence. On leaving school, Dr. Clarke attended Bristol University and received his B.A. in Psychology. At London University he obtained an M.A. in Clinical Psychology. Students studying for their master’s degrees had to undertake a small research study, which he found so enjoyable that he knew he wanted to be a researcher, not a clinical psychologist. He then applied for a job paid for by the Home Office, the UK’s equivalent of the U.S. Department of Justice, to undertake research for a group of 30 training schools for delinquents.

Building on this experience, he broadened his scope as a criminologist, strengthening his belief that the goal of Criminology should be to benefit society by seeking to reduce crime, beyond simply understanding and explaining it. To this end, his goal has been to improve the effectiveness and the reach of situational prevention. Coming full circle, Dr. Clarke has worked with other like-minded criminologists to establish the field of Environmental Criminology. This umbrella term covers a cluster of theories of crime, including crime pattern theory, routine activities theory and rational choice theory, and related preventive concepts such as situational prevention, defensible space, designing out crime and problem-oriented policing. He also helped create the Environmental Crime and Crime Analysis Symposium, which has met in many countries of the world in the past 22 years. Currently, Dr. Clarke continues to undertake empirical studies, often with graduate students, focused mainly on the illegal wildlife trade and poaching. These studies, undertaken in many parts of the world, afford him the opportunity to photograph birds, his consuming hobby.

For more information, visit http://rscj.newark.rutgers.edu/about/centers-institutes/

Awarded the Stockholm Prize in Criminology, June 2015

Guest at Her Majesty’s Garden Party in Buckingham Palace, July 1984